RecalledRecall 09-134Published

Old Navy Stuffed Animal and Creature Toys

Old Navy Recalls Stuffed Toys; Button Eyes Can Detach and Pose a Choking Hazard to Young Children

Hazard
Choking
Units
About 35,500 units
Incidents
None reported
Remedy
See the notice

CPSC recall 09-134, announced February 19, 2009, covers Old Navy Stuffed Animal and Creature Toys (about 35,500 units). The stuffed toys have two button eyes that could detach from the toy, posing a choking hazard to young children. The notice reports no incidents. Consumers should immediately take the recalled stuffed toy away from young children and return it to any Old Navy store for a full refund. Recall contact: call (866) 580-9930, go to www.oldnavy.com, or email custserv@oldnavy.com.

Advertisements

What to check on the product label

Compare the model on your label, then check any serial numbers, date codes, and exclusions in the notice. A model match alone does not confirm that your unit is included.

The CPSC data does not provide a discrete model-number list for this record. Compare the product description and identification details on the official notice.

Additional identifying details

Poopsie) 612738 Brown Penguin 612672 Light Pink Rabbit 612671 Brown Reindeer 612728 Dark Pink Rabbit (Honey O'Bunny) 612806 The style number is located on a white label sewn into the side seam of the toy.

Which products are included?

The stuffed animal and creature toys are made out of cotton and have plastic button eyes. They come in a variety of styles, such as a rabbit, penguin and reindeer. The recalled toys and style numbers are listed below: Type of Stuffed Toy Style Number Brown Plaid Creature (Stubby Stuberson) 612756 Pink Striped Dove 600571 Gray Dog 600572 Hot Pink Creature (Lucy Toothy) 612800 White Dog (Dr. Poopsie) 612738 Brown Penguin 612672 Light Pink Rabbit 612671 Brown Reindeer 612728 Dark Pink Rabbit (Honey O'Bunny) 612806 The style number is located on a white label sewn into the side seam of the toy.

Confirm these details on the official CPSC notice

What to look for

Also in the notice
Item or SKU numbers. Compare these as well.
Where to look
a white label sewn into the side seam of the toy (the notice’s words)
When sold
July 2008 through February 2009
Price paid
$6 to $10

Why it was recalled

The stuffed toys have two button eyes that could detach from the toy, posing a choking hazard to young children.

Incidents and injuries

None reported.

Official remedy

Consumers should immediately take the recalled stuffed toy away from young children and return it to any Old Navy store for a full refund. If purchased online, contact Old Navy for instructions on returning the toy for a full refund. Consumers who return the toy before July 1, 2009 will also receive a $5 coupon toward a future Old Navy purchase.

What to do now

  1. Check the product. This notice lists no model numbers. Compare yours with the description and photos in the official notice.
  2. Contact the firm. Call (866) 580-9930, go to www.oldnavy.com, or email custserv@oldnavy.com.
  3. Read the official notice. The CPSC notice is the final word on which units are included and what to do.

Advertisements

Product and sales details

Product type
Toys & play sets
Recall number
09-134
Units
About 35,500 in the United States and 5,400 in Canada
Manufactured in
China
Sold at / sales period
Old Navy stores and on the Web at www.oldnavy.com from July 2008 through February 2009 for between $6 and $10.
Distributor
Old Navy LLC, of San Francisco, Calif.

Stuffed Animal and Creature Toys

CPSC product type: Toy Animals Stuffed/Not Stuffed

This recall in context

Compared with the 1,130 toy recalls in this index, as of November 20, 2026.

Size
35,500 units: the 233rd-largest of 730 toy recalls that state a unit count. The median is 10,625 units.
Hazard
Choking: named in 584 of 1,130 toy recalls, the most common hazard among them.
Brand history
Old Navy is named in 4 CPSC notices in this index, from 2004 to 2012. This recall is the 3rd. The one before: Old Navy Performance Fleece-Lined boys' jackets (08-108, Dec 2007).
Time on sale
8 months. Recalled the same month the notice says sales ended.

Recall contact information

For additional information, contact Old Navy toll-free at (866) 580-9930 between 9 a.m. and 9 p.m. ET Monday through Friday, or between 12 p.m. and 7 p.m. ET on Saturday, visit the firm's Web site at www.oldnavy.com, or e-mail the firm at custserv@oldnavy.com

Verify phone numbers, hours, and websites on the current CPSC notice before contacting the firm.

Know someone who has one?

Recalls only work when owners hear about them. Send this notice to family or friends who might own the same product.

Advertisements

Related recalls

Other notices from the same brand or product category.