CPSC recall 18-763, announced August 29, 2018, covers BSN SPORTS Rubber critter toys (about 31,200 units). The orange and yellow surface paint on the rubber critter toys contains levels of lead that exceed the federal lead paint ban. The notice reports no incidents. Consumers should immediately take the recalled rubber critter toys away from children and contact BSN SPORTS for a merchandise credit. Recall contact: call 888-847-8816, or go to www.bsnsports.com.
Advertisements
Compare the model on your label, then check any serial numbers, date codes, and exclusions in the notice. A model match alone does not confirm that your unit is included.
The CPSC data does not provide a discrete model-number list for this record. Compare the product description and identification details on the official notice.
Which products are included?
This recall involves all rubber critter toys sold in various colors and animal shapes including octopus, alligators, chickens, frogs, pigs, penguins and cows. The toys are primarily used to play physical education tossing games. They were sold individually and in sets ranging from two to 24 rubber critters.
Confirm these details on the official CPSC noticeWhat to look for
- When sold
- February 2017 through June 2018
- Where sold
- Amazon, among the sellers the notice names
- Price paid
- $10 to $145
Why it was recalled
The orange and yellow surface paint on the rubber critter toys contains levels of lead that exceed the federal lead paint ban. Lead is toxic if ingested by young children and can cause adverse health issues.
Incidents and injuries
None reported
Official remedy
Consumers should immediately take the recalled rubber critter toys away from children and contact BSN SPORTS for a merchandise credit. BSN SPORTS is contacting all known purchasers directly.
What to do now
- Check the product. This notice lists no model numbers. Compare yours with the description and photos in the official notice.
- Contact the firm. Call 888-847-8816, or go to www.bsnsports.com.
- Get the remedy. This recall offers a refund. The notice says the firm is contacting known buyers directly.
- Read the official notice. The CPSC notice is the final word on which units are included and what to do.
Advertisements
Product and sales details
- Brand
- BSN SPORTS
- Product type
- Toys & play sets
- Recall number
- 18-763
- Units
- About 31,200
- Manufactured in
- China
- Sold at / sales period
- BSN SPORTS and US Games catalogs, and online at www.amazon.com, www.athleticconnection.com, www.bsnsports.com, www.esportsonline.com and www.usgames.com from February 2017 through June 2018 for about $10 for an individual rubber critter and up to $145 for a set.
- Importer
- BSN SPORTS LLC, of Farmers Branch, Texas
- Distributor
- BSN SPORTS LLC, of Farmers Branch, Texas
This recall in context
Compared with the 1,130 toy recalls in this index, as of November 20, 2026.
- Size
- 31,200 units: the 239th-largest of 730 toy recalls that state a unit count. The median is 10,625 units.
- Hazard
- Ingestion: named in 138 of 1,130 toy recalls.
- Remedy
- Refund: offered in 233 of 1,130 toy recalls, the most common remedy.
- Time on sale
- 17 months. Recalled 2 months after the last month of sales the notice gives.
Recall contact information
BSN SPORTS toll free at 888-847-8816 Monday through Friday from 7 a.m. to 6 p.p. CT or online at www.bsnsports.com, www.usgames.com, www.athleticconnection.com and www.esportsonline.com and click on the product recall link at the bottom of the page or www.recallrtr.com/rubbercritters for more information.
Verify phone numbers, hours, and websites on the current CPSC notice before contacting the firm.
Know someone who has one?
Recalls only work when owners hear about them. Send this notice to family or friends who might own the same product.
Advertisements




